Wednesday, December 10, 2014

When Will We Ever Win?

Is the new “transparency” of the government legitimate, or is it simply politically expedient. The release by a committee on alleged CIA torture programs was a calculated risk, which showed in real time that the Democrats are just as willing to throw our country under the bus as the Republicans. The lives and futures of former operatives and managers within the intelligence and legal communities are at risk. While we may not extradite an American under human rights violations or war crimes charges, we may never be able to effectively use their expertise on foreign soil again.

I have been steadily amazed at the proclivity of the United States to engage in limited wars. We send our young people into battles that would not be in our political, security, or economic interests to win. They come home to a bureaucracy that is famed for providing critical care posthumously, and some come home to prison sentences for actions that would have gotten them decorated in other countries.

Since Viet Nam, or so the saying goes, the United States has been reluctant to face a formidable enemy, preferring to engage in “backward and tactically inept” forces. But over the past forty years we have had our lunch money stolen by those very forces. Actually, we lost our taste for war, at least privately, after Hiroshima and Nagasaki. What followed was a space and weapons race that nearly bankrupted both governments involved. We developed weaponry capable of destroying battalions and divisions of soldiers, battle ships and cruisers, and all we are fighting are squads and platoons of guerrilla fighters.
We plan for battle with great forces, and we are getting beaten by their bush leagues.

The reason for this, anymore, is the threat of hindsight. If a platoon clears a village and roots out enemy clandestine forces (who wears a uniform anymore?) and a family is caught up as collateral damage, which sergeant or lieutenant is going to prison for life once the Monday morning quarterbacks are finished? As a former NCO, if I had to try and second guess what the clerks in the Pentagon were going to determine, I'd probably lose a foot in a hunting accident before deployment. In the military it appears that with the exception of the Navy, they tend to punish at the lowest possible, most disposable level in the ranks. The Navy relieves and subjects Captains (Colonels) to everyone else for unsatisfactory results, embarrassing incidents, and even accidents, that occur on their watches.


As long as our civilian politicians are willing to tell tales (substantiated or not) out of school, and our senior military commanders are not subject to the same rules we imposed on the Japanese and German officers, we may have the best equipped, best trained, and the most motivated military machine in the world.   But until we allow our generals the leeway to fight the war to the best of their abilities; until we realize that collateral damage is going to occur; and until Americans are comfortable with the concept of winning a war in the proper way (by destruction of the enemy), we should not consider deploying another soldier into battle.

We also have to face the fact that in the case of ISIS we are fighting a proxy war.  Just as we supplied the Taliban in Afghanistan's fight with Russia; someone else is doing the same for them.  We need to follow the money, the logistics, and the materials trails to their source, and eliminate that support there. 

No comments:

Post a Comment