There are some basic
facts that should be addressed regarding the Malaysian Flight 17
incident. Regardless of who is responsible for the shoot-down; the
perpetrators will be punished. Vladimir Putin is in a far more
precarious position than President Obama. At the end of Obama's
term, he will retire in peace. Putin's reign could be cut short by
internal forces, which could cost him his life. Russians aren't big
on pensioning their leaders.
My own supposition on
this event is that an element of the “rebel” or Ukrainian national
forces went rogue, and simply ignored their chain of command. Such a
failure to control their forces would seriously affect the world view
of the Ukrainian nationalists. Putin cannot admit to a loss of
control, for that could well be fatal for him personally. We are
holding Putin responsible for acts that he did not commit, and that
he was probably unaware of at the time of occurrence. This would be
like holding President Obama or Bush responsible for the war crimes
of which we have convicted our own soldiers in the Middle East. The
penalties for those actions are not related to the crimes of war, but
to the damage done to our international image.
The press is making a lot
of noise about preservation of the crash site. The people who live
in the area are poor. War has destroyed their livelihoods, and the
recovery of salable items is essential to their survival. The Ukrainians, rebels
and the Russians are not going to stop the plundering because when
evidence is destroyed, no definitive conclusion can be drawn as to
responsibility. The Ukrainian government cannot enforce laws in
territory it does not control.
As to claims and counter
claims, it is in the political best interest of the nations involved
to affix blame on the other. But, in the grand scheme of things,
this event was, at the risk of sounding cynical and jaded, an error of war.
No more, no less. In combat, errors occur. Aircraft identification
at that altitude is difficult, if not impossible for the average
human field of vision. The gunner of the missile system followed the
orders of his commander. Failure to do so would have resulted in
summary justice.
I would recommend that
the victims be mourned, the bodies returned to their homelands, and
that we pressure both sides to end this war. The end may be
compromise, and in compromise there is always an unsatisfied side.
I doubt that we shall see, in this conflict, another error as gross
as this; and I would surmise that the responsible parties will be dealt with.
Therefore, the press for peace and stabilityt is more important than the assignment of fault or blame.