There are many arguments
for and against the death penalty. The latest batch stem from
suppliers refusing to manufacture or sell the chemicals used in
lethal injections. With that issue, it appears that prisons are
mixing their own cocktails and the visible results are not fit for
public consumption. The condemned do not die a “clean” death as
is illustrated in the movies. They thrash, convulse, and probably
undergo a great deal of pain as their bodies fight the death process.
Witnesses are put off by the scene, and in the last Oklahoma
execution the blinds around the death room had to be drawn closed to
prevent discomfort among the witnesses.
It costs a state
approximately seven million dollars to execute one person. This
includes security, the cost of automatic appeals, and feeding,
housing, and clothing that inmate. If the inmate develops a terminal
illness, another million or two is spent to keep that inmate alive
until the execution date. A life sentence without possibility of
parole costs about a million dollars.
Additionally, an inmate
serving life without parole doesn't have the luxuries the condemned
inmate enjoys. Unless the inmate is a management problem, that
inmate goes to yard with the rest of the population and faces the
same risks as any other incarcerated inmate. A lifer doesn't have
unfettered telephone access. A lifer eats in the dining hall, he
does not get “room service” like a condemned inmate.
We are a compassionate
society. We don't want to impose cruel or unusual punishment on our
condemned inmates. We can't hang them, because their heads pop off
occasionally. We can't electrocute them, because they get burned.
We can't gas them because they suffer pain in their last moments.
Now we can't drug them because of “complications”. Firing squads
are ok until one group of intrepid marksmen miss their target spot.
Life without parole seems to be the only alternative.
The problem with that
sentence is that it can be handed down with a lot less stress to the
conscience than the death penalty. Race, the quality of defense
counsel, financial status of the defendant, and the integrity of the
police, prosecutor, and the judge, all come into play. The mental
set of “I'm not killing him, so what's the problem?” comes into
play. Appeals can either reduce the sentence or exonerate the
individual later. Appeals and dedicated appellate attorneys will
dwindle when the state is no longer picking up the bill. The
crusaders can only save so many, and my guess is that they save
probably ten percent of the wrongly accused and sentenced. Many of
the innocent don't have a press agent.
I'm against the death
penalty. Not for moral reasons, but because the penalty is
capriciously and disproportionately imposed on the poor, the
minorities, and the mentally ill and the costs are ridiculous. The
only purpose for the death penalty is revenge. Removing the person
from society is accomplished with a life sentence, and isolation from
normal human beings is accomplished with a lower cost, and a cleaner
conscience......