Thursday, March 6, 2014

Accountability of Commanders Regarding Sexual Misconduct in the Military

The Senate defeated the bill that would have made a dent in sexual assault cases in the military. However, if there were a legislator who worked this issue correctly, the problem would be solved.

Senator Gillebrand wants to remove the authority for prosecuting and affirming sentences for sexual misconduct from the chain of command. Unfortunately, that isn't the way any military functions, and it should not. The ultimate responsibility for the success of training, accomplishment of the mission, and the winning of a war, rests with the Chain of Command. Command cannot be established or maintained by committee, and therefore the responsibility must rest with one person.

In the military, authority can be delegated, but responsibility cannot. The navies of the world have followed this dictum for generations. A captain who cannot or will not command, does not keep his ship. If an officer under his command fails, then the Captain is considered a failure as well, because he did not step in and provide guidance or assistance to insure success. Both careers are essentially over. Both problematic personnel are removed from the equation.

This is the area where the Senator has failed to utilize basic military law and doctrine. If an occurrence of sexual assault, misconduct, or crime is alleged, an investigation must take place. The military has special agents with police powers to investigate. In the case of an alleged officer involved incident, after the military police investigation, there is an investigation by an independent commissioned officer, assisted by the JAG office on the installation. That is called an Article 32 Investigation. The officer prepares the report and submits it to the commander with courts martial convening authority, who then decides whether or not to prosecute. In the case of a commissioned officer, that authority is reserved to the commander holding flag rank at the installation (i.e. the ranking general officer).

If Congress were to state that a sexual crime was not prosecuted due to command influence, an article in the Uniform Code of Military Justice titled misprision of a felony covers it. That article states that anyone who knows of a crime committed, but refuses to report or act on it, is guilty of that article. This article applies to all members of the armed forces.

The key is not to take the command prerogative away from commanders, but to ensure they exercise it within the letter and spirit of the law. The Military Justice System of the United States Armed Forces is probably the best and most fair system of justice on earth. If commanders are suborning it, then those commanders need to be held accountable and fired. An officer with between 18 and 30 years of service is practically guaranteed his pension and benefits, plus a nice job, upon retirement. However, if these officers were subject to courts-martial and dismissal from the service with forfeitures of all pay and allowances, plus a felony conviction record, perhaps, judgment and honor would prevail over covering for their Academy classmates. As it stands, there are countless colonels in the Army who occupy small meaningless offices on out of the way installations, simply to save either their pensions or their family name.

When we retire a General Officer for covering up or allowing an instance of adultery, rape, forcible sodomy, or having an affair with a subordinate or subordinate's spouse, justice is not served. Elevated rank means that the holder of that rank should know better. The officer who covers up the offense should be subject to the same charges as the offender.  That is responsibility.

No comments:

Post a Comment