Monday, December 13, 2010

How About a Radical Idea?

The United States is caught up in a manufactured and well marketed miasma of fear.  Decades ago, manufacturers moved most of their operations to other countries.  This move was dictated by economic necessity.  Environmental laws and labor costs destroyed American manufacturing.  Now the fear of "foreigners" taking what jobs remain, is rampant.  Historically, America has sought the services of foreign nationals, from all countries, to settle frontiers, build infrastructure, and do jobs "unsuitable" for Americans.  The unsuitable part was created by the bankers and investors of a new nation.  If a foreigner died or was maimed on a job, no one complained.  Foreigners did not have access to congressmen, OSHA did not exist, and no one except a few kooks stood up for them.

NAFTA did not go far enough.  If NAFTA were to be scrapped, with the alternative to bilaterally opening the borders between both our neighbors and ourselves, eliminating tariffs, and allowing both trade and travel, a lot of the nonsense that exists now would evaporate.  If the United States were to initiate this concept, we would find out who our friends really are.  But we would also get a lesson in international relations.  The Canadians would not accept the border opening.  Their trade policies are far more protectionist and isolationist than ours.  Opening the borders with Mexico would fail, because Mexico would lose tariffs on imports.  Anything electronic, purchased in Mexico, is twice the price that is charged for the same product north of the border.  Opening the border would allow Mexicans to circumvent the tariff collections.  Instead of drug transporting wars, there would be wars over the right to transport electronic goods.
The US is not clean in this area either.  Boots and shoes made in Mexico are of great quality.  The variance is illustrated in the difference in sales price.  A good pair of western boots, without the label of the famous boot makers, but built by the same, are 70 to 90% cheaper when purchased in a store in Mexico.  Some of the markup is greed, but I'll bet a lot is tariff driven.


Times are hard throughout the Americas. Sharing the borders, allowing the opportunities and the goods to flow with less restriction and cost, would only allow the countries to be true mutual friends.  Open the borders, open the opportunities.

No comments:

Post a Comment